|
|
|
|
|
3rd Safarul Muzaffer 1436 | Thursday, Nov 27, 2014
Top Stories

Deoband issues fatwa banning photography as un-Islamic

Wednesday, 11 September 2013
Comments(66)
New Delhi, September 11:

India's leading Islamic seminary Darul Uloom has issued a fatwa, saying "photography is unlawful and a sin", even though Saudi Arabia allows photographers inside the holy city of Mecca and live telecast of 'namaz' is beamed on Islamic channels across the world.
Mufti Abdul Qasim Nomani, Mohtamim (Vice-Chancellor) of Darul Uloom Deoband, said on the phone, "Photography is un-Islamic. Muslims are not allowed to get their photos clicked unless it is for an identity card or for making a passport."

He said Islam does not permit video-taping of marriages or clicking of pictures to save as mementos for future generations.

When pointed out that Saudi Arabia, which follows the Wahabi school that aspires to return to the earliest fundamental sources of Islam, allows photography in the holiest of Islamic cities Mecca and beams live coverage through the year, Nomani said, "Let them do it. We do not allow it. Not everything they do is correct."

Nomani agreed with the fatwa -- a religious edict issued by Darul Ifta in Deoband -- regarding a query from an engineering graduate saying he was passionate about photography and wanted to pursue it as a career.

"Photography is unlawful and sin. Hadith (recorded Islamic tradition) warns sternly against it. Do not do this course. You should search any suitable job based on your engineering course," reads the fatwa posted on the school's website.

All India Muslim Law Personal Board member Mufti Abul Irfan Qadri Razzaqi also agreed with Nomani's fatwa.

"Islam forbids photographing of humans and animals. Whoever does that will be answerable to God," Razzaqi told .

When reminded that Saudis allow it, he said, "Just because they are richer than us doesn't mean they are also correct. If they are allowing photography they will be answerable on the Day of Judgment in the court of God."

----PTi

Latest News

Naseeruddin Shah launches his memoir '...

Naseeruddin Shah recently launched his memoir titled 'And Then One Day: A Memoir' in Mumbai. The book is said to be a candid recount of ...

Hughes' 'bouncer bowler' Abbott going through 'incre...

Australian cricket team doctor Peter Brukner has said that domestic side New South Wales bowler Sean ...

Germany unveils special jet to transport Ebola patients

The German government unveiled Thursday at Berlin's Tegel Airport a special medical evacuation plan ...

Related News

Modi returns home, says "Thank You, Kathmandu"

Prime Minister Narendra Modi tonight returned here after a three-day visit to Nepal where he attende ...

11 headless bodies found in southern Mexico

Police found 11 headless bodies of young men Thursday on the road between Chilapa de Alvarez and Aya ...

Saudi announces new policy for pilgrims

The Government of Saudia Arabia has announced its new policy for pilgrims of Holy Haj and Umrah. ...

Koun kya Ukad layndow.............

What Deoband Say They are Correct…………..Qalas maffi Gir Gir
Ulema Deoband jow bhi boltay Quran aur sunnath ki roushni may hi boltay haan agar koi un ka naam rakay badnam karrah toh aur bath hai.
This is good and right fatwa we muslims Accept 100% u R Right Please Issue Strong Fatwa We are ready any time to accept don’t fear like Giremuqaleed ,jamai nazamia and jamthislam all will fear with govt of India and KSA.
We are with u we will die for you if u r on Haq Everyt Time no one in this world can challenge isnahllah as u right ulema-e-deoband always.
Ulema Deoband k wajay say hi Hindustan azaad hua jow un ku nahi manta India **** k chalay jawo bus maffi gir gir.

Camels urine

Deoband please clarify,whether drinking camels urine is advised by prophet(pbuh) or not.
Unfortunately there is a lot of confusion on this matter.

Re:Benefits of camel urine

A very relevant question.
As per the advise of the prophet,there are lot of benefits of camels urine and just as Hindus use ganga water to purify their homes,as a sip to the dying man,camels urine is similarly to be used by Muslims.
Due to ignorance and lack of research the issue has been not dealt with in detail.

@anjum

Yes great, when everything else fails it is very easy to change names and post lies & distortions for self satisfaction, what more can be expected from losers of the worst kind.

it seems you are a great research scholar, would you mind telling us where exactly it is mentioned in Islamic Texts of your new find "thesis" related to camels urine??

What You Know.....

Aray Lounday ummath may iqtaylaf math paida kar us k pashab kaiku kampada tayray ku pani pina ray zaroorath paday toh nahi toh tayra amma ka pashaab pee nahi toh tayri biwi ka pee wo peenay kaiku jara waisay maseel waqti taur pay kahen toh muzakara aya rah riwayath may daruloom ka website hai dek mail kar zaroorath padi toh.................

Cow urine

You are simply making a fool of yourself by posting comments with fake identities, it seems too much cow urine drinking is taking its toll on you.

advised for you Hasan Bindu

Yes, all those who drink all kinds of Urine and Camel's urine is fine too. You don't need deoband to confirm. I smell urine with your comments, so it was easy :)

No it's not allowed by Prophet S.A.W

Dear, If you want to ask this to Dar ul Uloom Deoband then, they have a special website for Fatawa there you can go easily and ask them to get an authentic answer. But regarding this matter already I got to know it by a scholar that during the Period of Prophet Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam there came in Madinah a tribe wherein most of the people of that particular tribe got a disease and therefore Prophet Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam said to them to drink the camel urine for their cure but it was not allowed for others and for always. It was allowed to some particular people for some particular reason not for always. Anyhow you can be well ascertained by posting your question to the Fatawa website of Darul Uloom Deoband.

Say something and be in news.

Why we make mockery of ourselves on daily basis? I want to ask Mufti Abdul Qasim (VC Darul Uloom Deoband) if he ever performed HAJJ or UMRAH and if he have PASSPORT, AADHAAR CARD or RATION CARD, if yes then he should take back his FATWA.

You Nonsense mocking of yourself

It is clearly mentioned in the Fatwa that for important works like Passport, Aadhar Card or any other identity purpose it is allowed. And whoever allows it are responsible to Allah on Qiyamath day.

Passport

Arrey bhai, mera ek doubt tha, kya mohammed miyan jab madiney ku gaye tho unkey paas passport tha kya ?

What is darul uloom.. Do

What is darul uloom.. Do they follow authentic ahadis... They just try to impose man-made stories and enlist as fiqh hanafia... Theier aqaid are marjia as per shaikhul hind abdul khadar jeelani rahimahullah (ghanyatu talibeen)... Marjai firqa has 12 grops in which hanafi is one of them they have theier own way of contradicting with ahadith basically on tauheed. Allahs existance.

You are a follower to Idiots that's why you blame to Darul uloom

Dear, who are you to say which hadeeth is authentic. You are really a fool and Non sense and a good liker of the Pig eaters (christians) which in turn is stools eater. Because Ahle Hadeeth in India are the one named by the Christian Britishers to safeguard themselves from the reaction of Muslims. So, I request each of the reader here to understand the value of the Greatest Islamic Institution of India and don't care these penny people who wants to become of more importance not by the struggles but by criticizing those who are struggling for Islam.

Is it okay for Islam to move

Is it okay for Islam to move out of the desert tents into the modern world? Things that made sense back then, don't make sense now. Do these fatwa issuers have anything better to comment about?

Sense and sensibility

Posting senseless comments at 4 in the morning is the work of a senseless person who has got nothing worthwhile to do.

Fatwa e Razvia Read

video me aks nahi hota hai
agar fatwa chaiye to Fatawa e Razwia me dhondlo bhatkoge nahi musalamano

Mufti Sahab Ko Chodo Bhai

Leave Moulvi Sahab or Mufti Sahab. It is the responsibility of every single muslim to help his brother/sister teaching deen. Work individually or collectively. Join Br. Zahid Ali Khan Sahab in his efforts to uplift Muslim Ummah. Allah Subhanhu Wa Taala give this brother health and long life. Aameen

Education is the key to success in this world and hereafter. The first verse revealed to our beloved Prophet Sallal Lahu Alaihi Wasallam was "READ IN THE NAME OF YOUR LORD" and this was for both Men and Women. It means Allah swt want us to be educated. Unfortunately, we Muslims who showed the light to the world are in the darkness now.

Every muslim should read Quran with translation (Tafseer also) and Seerah of our beloved Prophet pbuh. How his beloved daughter Fatima got married? What was her Jahez and dowry etc. Otherwise we are going to be in Qasarah always.

We follow shaitaan every where. We do every wrong thing especially in Weddings. Doing all kinds of Rusumaat which are un-Islamic and has no sence at all. It starts from selection of spouse. Though the boy is neither handsome nor beautiful but looking for a beautiful, very fair color, highly educated girl. Then comes demands. Joday ki Raqam, Dinner, Video Graphy, Band Baja and Nach Gaana. All these at whose expense. Not only that these photos and videos are loaded on You Tube for the world to see and make fun of us.

I suggest that we should start boycotting by not attendng these type of weddings.

Wakeup brothers and sisters, this is everyones responsibility to educate your relatives, friends, neighbors otherwise you will be responsible on the day of Judgement.

Lastly, I pray to Allah swt to guide us all on Sirat-ul-Mustaqim.

bhai

Please read the news properly and he is saying shariah. not own. prevention is better than cure. islam stand solution for before and after also always .Ask the scholar of deen about this fatwa. dont do own judgement.you.can own.judgement only if you have complete knowledge.of Quran.& Sunnah & history of islam.

Mufti Abdul Khasim Nomani - Reply

Abey bewakhoof pehle poori news accha padh phir samajh phir comment kar. Hawle they issued the fatwa based on a question posted by an engineering graduate. Aur maqanchoo photography ka jahez se kya lena dena hai re. Jo haram hai wo haram hai. Kisi bhi alime deen ko bura bolna bhi haram hai re pagal. Tauba kar ALLAH se

Mufti Abdul Khasim Nomani - Reply

Abey bewakhoof pehle poori news accha padh phir samajh phir comment kar. Hawle they issued the fatwa based on a question posted by an engineering graduate. Aur maqanchoo photography ka jahez se kya lena dena hai re. Jo haram hai wo haram hai. Kisi bhi alime deen ko bura bolna bhi haram hai re pagal. Tauba kar ALLAH se

Deoband issues fatwa banning photography as un-Islamic

Science and technology have no place in religious text - do not try to find justification for photography, or usage of mobiles or video or satellite dishes or internet or robotics or genetics in religious texts. The muftis have become irrelevant these days, with due respect to them. Its time now that Muslim youth get going without resorting to such dogmatic and backward-looking fatwas. Only do such things which are legal, legitimate and of course fear God in your actions and inter-action with others.

Reply to Mr. Anonymous in regards to Mufti Abdul Qasim Nomani

Assalamualeikum Bhai Saab ,mujhe to sab se pehley aapki baat pe tajub hai ke aap ne article sahi tareeqe se padha Nahin main Jo boloonga usein gaur se padhiye 1. Mufti Sahaba ne passport aur ID ke liye khicha saktey bole aur aapne aapki starting sentence galat likha 2. Aap me kahan ke fatwa Asia diya karo ke Islam aur insaniat ku dhakka an lage mere Bhai Islam aya hi insaniyat ku phelaney aapke ilm main kami dikhrahi hai , ladkiya to pehley se hi ziyada thi jode ki raqam wagaria aaphi ke Jaise kam ilm wale log nikale 3. Deeni talim ki Tara's rujuu ki baat Karein bohat achi baat hai liking mere Bhai aap me ki talim haasil agar ki aap yeh fatwa pe ke saat thair ke boltey thain ke mufti Saab sahi boley ,mufti Saab Jo bole Hadith ki Roshni main bole Jo Muhammad IBN Abdullah rasool ALLAH sallalahu Aleihi wa Sallam farmaye , jake Hadith padhiye Phir bolna yeh fatwe pe, aap kalmein ka meaning hi Nahin Sammie to yeh fatwa kya samjhingey 4. Bhai Saab aapne kahan behayai aam hote Jari to uska sab se bada reason photo hai to mufti Saab behayai khatam Karnei ki hi baat bole ab aap aapki nafs se dekhingey to galath hi dikhinga na.

Badi sharan ki baat hai ke aapke Jaise log jinku deen ka ABC Bhai Nahin ata ho nasihat dene baith jatey hai , pehley khud ku change kariye ilm nafein haasil ki jiye aur amale saleh ki jiye Phir doosro ku bolna.

SALAMUALEIKUM

Mufti saheb

Does this Fatwah applies to you? Checking on the internet, there are many photos of you giving speeches (Taqreer or Tafreeh). Please be an example before you pass these Fatwah or Fitnah.

Mufti is 100% right

Moulana Mufti Abdul Qasim Nomani Sahab is 100% right hai. Bhai saab agar maulana ho ya mufti ho koi bhi ho agar photo layta hai to wo khanooni majboori hai aur us ki maafi bhi hai jab tak photo nahi layengay tab tak passport nahi banta,aur hall ticket hai ya bus pass hai ya adhaar card hai ya ration card hai ya registry hai aye say kaee hamari mujboori hai ok . Now mufti saab ka kahna hai kay qairwajhay say koi photo ya video mat lo jo quran may wazay taor pay bataya gaya hai. Aur photography ya videography ka karobar islami hisaab say galat hai aur shaadiu may ya koi aur funtions may photo ya video layna galat hai.Bhai saab kisi ko tanqeed karnaysay pehlay apnay giraybaad may daykho aur aap pay koi zabardasti nahi kar raha hai app ki apni marzee hai allah ki baat pay amal karna ya na karna wo aap ki apni marzee hai. please allah ka wasta hai kay etihaad payda karo aur logo may tamasha na bano bus allah say dua hai kay hum sub ko hidayat day aur ek doosray kay saat qhuloos aur mohabbat say rahnay ki hidayat day AMEEN.

Dumb argument

Another reason to have a a dumb argument over a dumb fatwa!!!
What about real problems in the society like JAHALAT.(majority are uneducated)
dowry, interest, alcohol, etc, etc.

We can live with jahalat,

We can live with jahalat, dowry, interest, alcohol etc., that's why there are no fatwas against these issues. It is in the interest of political parties and society that these issues continue.

Mufti Deobandi

The painting of human & animal are unlawful in islam, whereas the photograph & video is the image reflection, as the object is. Then according to deobandi they should stop looking into mirror also, bcoz that also reflect the image, as video or camera photography does. Alos they stop stop viewing TV & computer also which also displays photography & video. Prohibition should be on bad use of photography or videos. we can use video of islamic lecture or debate & spread it among muslim to make aware about islam & its correct belief. Also you can utilize about giving dawah to non muslim.

Who r Responsible..From (SAUDIA ARABIA)

Aray Loduday ALLAH k Rassol khud Mirror(ayna) dayknay ki dua batayae agar yae galath ho toh kyoun boltay, lagta hai tu munafiq Apany Emaan ku sahi karlay
Tu Koun Ray lounday We can use Bolnay wala muth k tahrath lay na ata tayray ku tayray bath say pata chalra aur we can us bolra ray mooh much namaz pad pahilay 5 time aur jamath may nikal sudar jata tu bhigda hua hai tu.
Ulma-E-Deoband are Right in this World Agar Ulmaa-E-Deaband na hotay toh Deen sara kab ki mit chukka hota Fazail k liyae Niazamuddin(Delhi Markaz) Masail k liyae Daroloom Deoband Allah ka taraf say Muntqab Hai yae log.

USELESS ISSUE

WE HAVE BILLIONS OF IMPORTANT ISSUES. DEOBAND IS STUCK IN A USELESS ISSUE.THEY NEVER PLAYED A ROLE IN ANY IMPORTANT ISSUES OF MUSLIM IN INDIA.FIRST THEY SUPPORT MODI AND KNOW THIS.

Ur Useless

Issue is not useless but ur useless. Just understand the article. A question was asked to Mufti Sahab and he answered to that question. And if you want to know what our Ulemas are doing just go and stay with them and then post ur comments.

useless fellow

hi useless ,show me the guts ,at least i put my name there ,why you are hiding yours,what ever you do i now you cont hide from your step father.

You put your name there to hide your identity

If you are really a muslim then you could not write so. Just you saw it a boiling matter and thrown your hen to cook there. But you don't know in this boiling matter your hen will be F***ed but not cooked. So, Idiot don't involve in other's religion matter. This matter pertains to only muslims who want to follow Islam and not for non muslims like you or loose muslims like you who want to follow own desires. And also this Fatwa is issued for that individual who seeked the guidance and it is never meant for the world of fools where you people reside in.

reply

maraybhai,aap ki comments say lagta hai kay aap naam kay musalmaan lagthay hai,kuan ki 1)ek mufti ki itni toheen say comments likhay,allah is kay liya laanath aap per bhajayngay. astakfar kar lay,agar aap acchay musalmaan hai aur deen aur islam ko acchi tarah jaanthay hai to us kay baray may kuch kahay,warna kaamosh rahay is may aap ki bahterey hai.aap kay comments say deendaar- musalmaan log aap ko acchi tarah samajh thay ki aap kay deen ki kya level hai.naik kaam samajh kar karay--gunah kay haqdaar ho gai.bhai sub zumaydari muftiyon per hi hai,aap batai aap deen kay khatir kya-kya kaam karay hai,is ummat kay her fard ki zumaydary hai ki 100% deen pay chalay aur dusroon ko is kidawat day.kahnay ko bahut hai,bus aap apni limit may rahay.

fatwa

Mufti, you are useless for Indian muslim. You do noting except to issue fatwas. There are many problems Indian muslims are facing specially education, employment and many social problems, where as you muftis are busy in issuing fatwas. Hence I advise you to just shut up.

NADAN ANDHI TAQLEEDI DEOBANDI ULMA

YE MUFTI HAZRAT PAHLE ...MIKE PE FATWA DYE THAY ...KE AZAN MIKE ME NAHIN DENA .......PHIR KHA KE CHALO FATWA WAPIS AB AZAN DO...PHIR FATWA JARI HUVA KE HUM MAGHRIB KI KOI CHEEZ ISTEMAL NAHIN KARINGE ....PAIDAL PHEERINGE LIKIN JAHAZ ME NAHIN BAITHINGE......................ILM SE JAHEL KI JAHALAT NAHIN GAYEE....NADAN KO ULTA TO PHIR NADAN HI NIKLA.........AIYENE E NOU SE DARNA TARZ E KOHN PE ADHNA .....MANZIL YEHI KATHIN HAI QOUMON KI ZINDEGI ME....

Fatwa

Assalamualaikum bhai sahab mufti sahab ku bolnae say Pehlae dikyae to sahi mufti sahab kiya Kaam karrahae hai phir apni Rae dijiyae khali paper pad kar Rae daena aasan hai zara jakar to daekyae

Syed

NO ONE SHOULD FOLLOW THEIR FATWA AS IT IS FIXED AND BOUGHT http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7GDWXjB9Ij0

reason

I totally agree with Deoband word by word.
If there is photo of humans or animals, the angels don't enter their house.

The rest disagreed are deviated minds.

Muslims prefer cable to Quran

More Muslims are interested in watching the cable T.V. rather than reading the Quran.
Though Muslims keep Quran respectably in their homes,they give importance to the cable TV.
If Muslims of old city have to choose between Islam and cable TV,it is a common knowledge what Muslims would choose.
Therefore the fatwa issued is very carried.

Its seems that you does not

Its seems that you does not have ILM and you are saying to Mufti of one of the biggest running madarasa in the entire world.
Fatawa will be given in the light of Quran and Sunnah. If you are not fallowing it then do not blame other. Ulti Ganga bahrahi hai. Jab Mufti sahi fatwa diye to tum ko Ulta lagta hai.

Its seems that you does not

Its seems that you does not have ILM and you are saying to Mufti of one of the biggest running madarasa in the entire world.
Fatawa will be given in the light of Quran and Sunnah. If you are not fallowing it then do not blame other. Ulti Ganga bahrahi hai. Jab Mufti sahi fatwa diye to tum ko Ulta lagta hai.

WHy Why

Instead of just saying its Haram, do they provide any justification why its is Haram. I think a justification will provide more awareness. Just by saying its Haraam you are creating more confusion.

LANAT HO JAHIL PER JO FATWA AUR AUFTI SB KY KLAF BAT KARTA HII?

AY jahil insaan you read quran & hadees, don't mix with do bado program of zak its good but only the Photography is un-Islamic is not allow in islam bcz Parda ka khayal nahi hoot, Bai Haiyi Aam hoti hai, more over photo is necessary identity card or for making a passport.

Boycott Facebook & Boycott Entertainment Media

posting pictures on popular social networking websites Facebook and Twitter on the ground that it is unIslamic.
The heads of the two popular Lucknow-based helplines, run for Shia and Sunni Muslims, have been flooded with phone calls asking if virtual profiles are Islamic.
You can't see someone's face on Facebook and decide that you want to be friends. Look for 'pyar aur mohabbat' (love) in real life. Virtual relationships are not 'faydaymand' (profitable)," Sunni Mufti Abul Irfan Naimul Halim Firagni Mahli told PTI on phone from Lucknow.
The Mufti wants youngsters to bond in the real and not the virtual world. Of the over 1,000 calls that the Mufti fields in a month on his popular helpline, more than 50 per cent questions are about Internet usage.
"If one is on Facebook for legitimate business purposes or for constructive purposes, then the account is justifiable," he said.
However, the Mufti is not pleased about women being on Facebook to make friends and is definitely against them uploading pictures on the social networking site.
Women should not post pictures on Facebook or anywhere else on the Internet. This is unIslamic," he said.

Do social monitoring of kids - stop handing over smart phones

A person is a product of his or her environment. We can become proactive, and actively seek and create a positive environment at home and outside that would allow us to shape and mold our children’s character and identity, thereby create a model community. Or we can allow our children’s views and values to be formed / influenced, shaped and molded by the media and bad company, as their eyes and ears absorb the harmful images and information during the course of development of their minds and personality. (Do not underestimate the power of images, onslaught of media and peer pressure which lead to slow and steady undesirable and unconscious transformation of our boys & girls who reflect our community).
Listening and viewing creates awareness and turns into action. Watch and take care of what your children are exposed to and don’t let them get influenced by anti-social elements. Do social monitoring of your children – whether they are going on line socially – what are they doing there – watch for change in behavior and activities. Take corrective action before it is too late.

Photography Promotes Promiscuity, Vices, Diseases ...

INTERNET TWO-HEADED MONSTER OF 21ST CENTURY
Understand how imagery works on the imagination:
Do not underestimate the power of images. Islam prohibits images for good reasons. Images have the power to transform vision. Imagery goes beyond the intellect, through the emotions, into the imagination. That is where we live: in the imagination. Imagery has the capacity to go beyond the intellect, through the emotions, into the imagination, so the intellect is influenced and the emotions are ignited.
Nowadays we are confronted with powerful images in movies, internet, social media and magazines. The media is adept in creating visual impressions and impress on its viewers a different vision of the world. The visual power effects imagination refurbishing it with alternative visions which are transforming the Muslims community in their images.
Social consequences of internet abuse:
Young and old who have access to pervasive porn are prone to:
a) Psychiatric problems due to sex obsession;
b) Violent actions such as rape of minors and incest;
c) Killings after rape to do away with evidence of crime;
d) Illegitimate relationships outside the marriage;
e) Sexually transmitted diseases due to oral sex e.g. HPV, etc
f) Breakdown of marriages due to higher expectations of
longer sex by porn-watching women;
g) Lack of focus on education due to development of pervert
mentality developed due to porn-obsession;
h) Unwanted pregnancies and abortions by teenagers who are
victims of their peers;
i) Loss of interest by boy and girls to get married as they are fulfilling their sensual pleasures by watching porn and manual acts which is also promoting lesbianism and homosexuality;

Darul-uloom deoband issued

Darul-uloom deoband issued fatwa based on Islamic ruling which is 100% right. These days media trying to blame these Islamic seminaries.

No it is not correct Fatwa.

No it is not correct Fatwa. Namaz or speeches Telecasting is duniya issue.
No budy can say due to telecast they go in jannah. Photograpy also same
Issue.

No it is not correct Fatwa.

No it is not correct Fatwa. Namaz or speeches Telecasting is duniya issue.
No budy can say due to telecast they go in jannah. Photograpy also same
Issue.

Mufti Abdul Qasim Nomani,

Mufti Abdul Qasim Nomani, Mohtamim (Vice-Chancellor)Saheb kia aap Haj Kare aur Indian Passport rakhte hain. Phir aap photo kaisa liye aap ka Haj qhobool nahi.
Mufti Saheb Aisa Fatwa diya karo jis is Islam aur Insaniyath ko Dhaka na lage aur Qawoom ko nicha na hone do.
Aaj 60% Muslim Ladhkiyan Lain Dain, Ghude Jode ki lanath sai apni Omer ki Haad Cross kar rahe hain. Aur isi wajhe sai Ghair Muslim Ladhkawoon kai sath Rishta banarahe hain.
Aaj aap jaise Muftiyoon ko chahiye kai Her Saher main, Her Gawon main, Her masjid main Is Haram Lanath kai khilaf Fatwe diya kare. Musalmanowo ko takeed kiya kare. Sharam karo aur Sabaq loo Mufti Saheb. Janab Zahid Ali Khan Saheb DO-BADO-PROGRAM arrange kar kai kai musalma khandaan ko khareeb kar rahe hain.
Ayenda ager koi aap Fatwa dena chate hain to sonch samjh kar diya karin. Aaj Musalman kis pasti ki taraf ja raha hai. Deen ki Taleem ka rujan kaam hote ja raha hai, Parda ka khayal nahi hai, Bai Haiyi Aam hote ja rahi hai.
Aap ko Photo ki sojhi hai. Sharam karo Mufti saheb

Reply to mr. Anonymous regarding mufti Sahab fatw

Assalamualeikum Bhai Saab ,mujhe to sab se pehley aapki baat pe tajub hai ke aap ne article sahi tareeqe se padha Nahin main Jo boloonga usein gaur se padhiye 1. Mufti Sahaba ne passport aur ID ke liye khicha saktey bole aur aapne aapki starting sentence galat likha 2. Aap me kahan ke fatwa Asia diya karo ke Islam aur insaniat ku dhakka an lage mere Bhai Islam aya hi insaniyat ku phelaney aapke ilm main kami dikhrahi hai , ladkiya to pehley se hi ziyada thi jode ki raqam wagaria aaphi ke Jaise kam ilm wale log nikale 3. Deeni talim ki Tara's rujuu ki baat Karein bohat achi baat hai liking mere Bhai aap me ki talim haasil agar ki aap yeh fatwa pe ke saat thair ke boltey thain ke mufti Saab sahi boley ,mufti Saab Jo bole Hadith ki Roshni main bole Jo Muhammad IBN Abdullah rasool ALLAH sallalahu Aleihi wa Sallam farmaye , jake Hadith padhiye Phir bolna yeh fatwe pe, aap kalmein ka meaning hi Nahin Sammie to yeh fatwa kya samjhingey 4. Bhai Saab aapne kahan behayai aam hote Jari to uska sab se bada reason photo hai to mufti Saab behayai khatam Karnei ki hi baat bole ab aap aapki nafs se dekhingey to galath hi dikhinga na.

Badi sharam ki baat hai ke aapke Jaise log jinku deen ka ABC Bhai Nahin ata ho nasihat dene baith jatey hai , pehley khud ku change kariye ilm nafein haasil ki jiye aur amale saleh ki jiye Phir doosro ku bolna.aur ek baat pehley aapne nam likhna shuru ki jiye anonymous bolke chupiye mat.

SALAMUALEIKUM

MY FRIEND READ THE FATWA

MY FRIEND READ THE FATWA CAREFULLY THAN ANSWER

MALOOM NAHI KAHAN SE AJATE

ek bar fir pado

as salamu ak
Bhai ye baat yaad rakho fatwa jab diya jata hai jab koi us talloq se koi sawal pochta hai.
Har musalman ko taqwa k hisab se apni zindagi guzarni hai.
Agar nai guzarra tu kam se kam fatwe ke hisab se aapni zindagi guzarni(kamzor imaanwale) mere jaise log.
Aur bhai plz ye apne apne alim saab(mulsab) ke pass jakar ye baat pocho ke tasweer banana kitna bada guhna hai ye tasweer banana kabira guhna hai plz conform aur dosro ko bolo.
Aur rahi baat ye mulsab kaisa gaye hajj ko. mere bhai is news ko aap fir se padho.
Majbori ke halat mein aap passport ya I.D ke liye aap photo lesakte hai.
Aur dosri baat bhai dowry sab ko maloom galat kaam hai gunha hai. Magar aaj ke musalman ko nai maloom ke photo lena bi bada guhna hai.
Plz kisi aalim ko(koi b maslak)kuch maat bolo
unke pass ilim hai aur hum jahhil hai.

ek bar fir pado

as salamu ak
Bhai ye baat yaad rakho fatwa jab diya jata hai jab koi us talloq se koi sawal pochta hai.
Har musalman ko taqwa k hisab se apni zindagi guzarni hai.
Agar nai guzarra tu kam se kam fatwe ke hisab se aapni zindagi guzarni(kamzor imaanwale) mere jaise log.
Aur bhai plz ye apne apne alim saab(mulsab) ke pass jakar ye baat pocho ke tasweer banana kitna bada guhna hai ye tasweer banana kabira guhna hai plz conform aur dosro ko bolo.
Aur rahi baat ye mulsab kaisa gaye hajj ko. mere bhai is news ko aap fir se padho.
Majbori ke halat mein aap passport ya I.D ke liye aap photo lesakte hai.
Aur dosri baat bhai dowry sab ko maloom galat kaam hai gunha hai. Magar aaj ke musalman ko nai maloom ke photo lena bi bada guhna hai.
Plz kisi aalim ko(koi b maslak)kuch maat bolo
unke pass ilim hai aur hum jahhil hai.

Read the post completely

Please read the post completely , it is clearly stated that it it is not allowed unless needed for passport or a visa . You have no right based on your lack of understanding , to comment on the person who has spent his life learning and teaching Allah's deen.
This is not something which was done randomly , but was in response to the student asking for guidance for the photography profession.
May Allah guide us all onto his correct and complete deen and the sunnah of the Prophet pbuh .

Janab lagta hai ke aap pura

Janab lagta hai ke aap pura fatwa naheen padae hain. Phir se padyae. Shanaqt card, passport vaghaira vaghaira is fatwa mae shamil naheen hai.

fatwa quran aur sunnat ke mutabiq hota hai. chahe zamana tasleem kara ya na karae. Pairwee sirf Allah swt aur uske Rasool (sas) ki hoti hai. Mufti agar her insaan ko khush kerne ki koshish kiya to wo mufti naheen balke taghooti siyastdaan ho ja ta hai.

App ke doosrae bataen jodhe ghodae ke lanat, parda, pasti, taleem, bae hayaee vaghaira bilkul doosrt hai aur Allah aap ko jaza de. ameen.

aapke humsafer bhai ek muqlis

Respect Scholars

Ulema Ambiya kay Waris Hai. Agar wo log bura karay to jawaab wo daingay. Aaap apni had cross mat karo. Aur Ulema- deen ki izzat karo.

This is how it happens

Someone goes and asks a question to the Muftis, they under the light of Quran and Hadith tell them what is right and what is wrong.

In the above case Mufti sahab just said what is right and what is wrong. Brother you say "Mufti Saheb Aisa Fatwa diya karo jis is Islam aur Insaniyath ko Dhaka na lage aur Qawoom ko nicha na hone do" Muftis cannot,should not and hopefully will not change the ruling according to our needs. Thats the speciality of our religion.....it DOES NOT CHANGE unlike other religions, we accept it even if it does not make sense to us or others.

A brief explanation about why photography is not allowed......During the time of the Prophet صلى الله عليه و سلم there existed various ways of producing a picture; e.g. carving, painting, tracing, drawing, etc. The Prophet صلى الله عليه و سلم prohibited all these different types of pictures. In other words, the Prophet صلى الله عليه و سلم declared that pictures are prohibited and not the means of taking the photo. The ruling of picture-making does not change by the changing of the tool with which the picture is produced.
The invention of a camera merely marks yet another method of taking a photo. In order to understand this further it is essential that you understand the definition of a photograph.
The Oxford Dictionary defines the term ‘photograph’ thus, “a picture taken by means of the chemical action of light on a sensitive film.”
The American heritage dictionary has defined it as “An image, especially a positive print, recorded by a camera and reproduced on a photosensitive surface.”
The Websters revised unabridged dictionary, “A picture or likeness obtained by photography.”
These citations prove that a photograph is a picture (and not a mere reflection). Therefore, they will fall in the ambit of the explicit prohibition which is found in numerous authentic Ahadith.

'Ali (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: "Shall I not send you on the same mission as the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) sent me? Do not leave any built-up tomb without levelling it, and do not leave any picture in any house without erasing it." (Reported by Muslim and al-Nisaa'i; this is the version narrated by al-Nisaa'i).

Ibn 'Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him and his father) reported that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "Every image-maker will be in the Fire, and for every image that he made a soul will be created for him, which will be punished in the Fire." Ibn 'Abbaas said: "If you must do that, make pictures of trees and other inanimate objects."

No doubt the efforts of Zahid sahab are commendable.

Its seems that you does not

Its seems that you does not have ILM and you are saying to Mufti of one of the biggest running madarasa in the entire world.
Fatawa will be given in the light of Quran and Sunnah. If you are not fallowing it then do not blame other. Ulti Ganga bahrahi hai. Jab Mufti sahi fatwa diye to tum ko Ulta lagta hai.

pagal hai kya re tu

pehle padh poora, phir comment kar.
English nai ati o kisi se tarjuma kara
pagal, hendre, jahel dikhra tu

First read then comment

Just by reading headline dont comment.

First read then comment

Just by reading headline dont comment.

Don't make stupid comments.

Don't make stupid comments. Mufti is like a judge. He gives ruling, he is there to give ruling based on Shariah. That his job.
Shame on you, you are criticizing an learned scholar.
The issue of dowry you are raising is different than the issue on hand. Do not confuse people with illiterate comments. Disrespecting ulema is a sign of decline of ummah.

Arey o chaman, pehle tu

Arey o chaman, pehle tu topic se related baat karna seekh, jo Mufti sahab farmaye bilkul sahi hai, tu bahut photos lene walon me se dikhra isliye dusre baton k zariye uspe parda daalra, and sabse bada choor zahid ali khan hai, khali dikhawa karta samne public me impression jamane, bad peeche sab kaamo me hai... Mufti sahab k jhooti k barabar bhi ilm nahi hai... bada aya dusron ku jawab dene... jaa ke apne ghar me dekh and sudhaar pehle... haula kahi ka

ILLITERATE MUFTIS

GOOD COMMENT......ATLEAST YOU ARE MORE LEARNED AND MINDFUL THAN THOSE FATWA GIVERS.

Taseer kashi haram hai - jhutlao mat

Tasweerkashi haram hai. Jhutao mat. Aapjo behai ki baat kar rahe hai in sab ki jad hai 'photography'. Ulema haq baat bataney mein jhutlana nahi chahiya, kisee bhi soorat mei. Aap

Post new comment

To combat spam, please enter the code in the image.

Rs. 26230 (Per 10g)

Opinion Poll
Do you think introduction of grills to separate ladies and gents in RTC buses add to travel woes?
YesNoCan't say

Matrimony | Photos | Videos | Search | Polls | Archives | Advertise | Letters

© The Siasat Daily, 2012. All rights reserved.
Jawaharlal Nehru Road, Abids, Hyderabad - 500001, Telangana, India
Tel: +91-40-24744180, Fax: +91-40-24603188
contact@siasat.com