|
|
|
|
|
5th Muharram 1436 | Friday, Oct 31, 2014
India

Judge reserves order on recusing from hearing Naroda Gaam case

Monday, 7 January 2013
Comments(0)
Ahmedabad, January 07:

The designated judge hearing the Naroda Gaam rioting case of 2002 today reserved order on an application seeking her recusal from the case.

Jyotsna Yagnik, who had earlier conducted trial in the Naroda Patiya massacre case and now also assigned the Naroda
Gaam rioting case, today decided to pronounce her order in the matter on January 11.

Former state minister Maya Kodnani, Babu Bajrangi and Kishan Korani, who are accused in this case along with 79
others, sought the judge to recuse herself from the case as she had held them guilty in the Naroda Patiya case.

In an application, they apprehended that they would not get fair trial if the same judge were to conduct hearing
against them.

In a judgement delivered in the Naroda Patiya case in August, Justice Yagnik held Kodnani, Bajrangi and Korani as
guilty and sentenced them and 28 others to life imprisonment.

On November 30, 2011 the Chief Justice of Gujarat High Court had issued a notification appointing her as a designated
judge for Naroda Gaam case.

We have apprehensions that if the same judge would preside over this case, it will deprive us of fair and
impartial trial.

There are elements of pre-conceived notion,pre-determination and pre-disposition in this scenario,"argued advocate Nirupam Nanavati who appeared for all the three accused.

We fear that there are chances of subject-bias and bias of judicial obstinacy. Therefore in the fitness of the case,
your honour should recuse herself form the case," he added.

During the post-Godhra riots, 11 people of the minority community were killed in Naroda Gaam area of the city. The
Supreme Court had in 2008 appointed Special Investigation Team (SIT) and later assigned the trial against the 82 accused to a special court.

Though technically both the cases of Patiya and Gaam area have different FIRs and different trials, both have
certain common witnesses and evidences upon which judicial opinion was formed and we were held guilty," Nanavati
submitted before the court.

And on the basis of similar sets of witnesses and evidences, if we would also be held guilty in this case, it
will be the travesty of justice," he added.

Opposing the request, special public prosecutor Suresh Shah contended that there was no provision in Criminal
Procedure Code to request a judge to recuse him/herself from a case by any party.

Following the SC orders, Chief Justice of the High Court has appointed a judicial officer and this court has no
role to change that decision," he stated.

------------------------------PTI

Latest News

One killed in Jammu and Kashmir accident

At least one person was killed and 28 people were injured late Thursday when a bus rolled down a dee ...

Shiv Sena to boycott Fadnavis oath ceremony

The Shiv Sena Friday announced a complete boycott of the swearing-in ceremony of the first BJP government in Maharashtra, scheduled later in ...

Jerusalem on edge after police kill Palest...

Clashes raged in east Jerusalem today after Israeli police shot dead a Palestinian accused of trying to kill a Jewish hardliner, as Al-Aqsa ...

Related News

Madras High Court passes order of compromise between teacher, mother of ...

Madras High Court today directed a teacher of a city based school to pay a compensation of Rs 50,000 ...

PM Modi remembers Indira Gandhi on her 30t...

Prime Minister Narendra Modi today remembered former prime minister Indira Gandhi on her 30th death anniversary. "I join my fellow countr ...

PM Modi pays floral tribute at Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel's statue in...

Prime Minister Narendra Modi paid floral tribute at the statue of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel near Parl ...

Post new comment

To combat spam, please enter the code in the image.

Rs. 26810 (Per 10g)

Opinion Poll
Do you think formation of 'She' teams would be beneficial for women's safety?
YesNoCan't say

Matrimony | Photos | Videos | Search | Polls | Archives | Advertise | Letters

© The Siasat Daily, 2012. All rights reserved.
Jawaharlal Nehru Road, Abids, Hyderabad - 500001, AP, India
Tel: +91-40-24744180, Fax: +91-40-24603188
contact@siasat.com