New Delhi: On August 12, railway minister Piyush Goyal congratulated Suresh Chavhanke on the 14th anniversary of his media venture Sudarshan News. “I hope your channel continues to inform truth to the people,” wrote Goyal.
A few months hence, Chavhanke ran a broadcast where he claimed that AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi ‘danced’ after the murder of Hindu Samaj leader Kamlesh Tiwari. Chavhanke played a video of Owaisi uploaded by ANI, where the leader can be seen imitating manoeuvring a kite (his party’s symbol). This was shot on October 17, a day before Tiwari was killed in Lucknow on October 18.
The programming head of Sudarshan News, Rajesh Rana, explained to Alt News that the misreport was due to a ‘confusion’. “ANI had uploaded the video on October 18, therefore, we interpreted that the clip was shot the same day,” he informed. It is noteworthy that though ANI had uploaded the video on October 18, its tweet clearly mentioned that the event was held the previous day.
Incidentally, Suresh Chavhanke tweeted ‘evidence’ of Owaisi ‘celebrating’ Tiwari’s murder soon after the channel’s conversation with Alt News. However, the video shared in his clarification was not the same clip used by Sudarshan News in its October 20 broadcast.
Apart from blatant disinformation, Chavhanke’s nearly one-hour long report had a persistent defamatory tone where he claimed Owaisi ‘danced’ in celebration of Tiwari’s murder. He suggested that the AIMIM leader should be locked behind bars. Those familiar with Chavhanke and his channel are not oblivious to their repeated targeting of the Muslim community.
On the occasion of World Environment Day observed earlier in June, Chavhanke had organised a ‘public parliament’ in Delhi’s Jantar Mantar to demand that a population control law is implemented in the country to deter further growth of Muslims in India. The rally, held with the support BJP MP Giriraj Singh, echoed anti-Muslim rhetoric from every corner.
This report will focus on the numerous cases of misinformation, which are often communal in nature, broadcast by Sudarshan News and propagated by its CMD and editor-in-chief, Suresh Chanvhanke, himself.
1. Disinformation about decree by mosque against UP police
In July 2018, Sudarshan News had published a report which claimed that a decree against UP police was passed by a mosque in Uttar Pradesh.
The news turned out to be false and was debunked by Alt News. There was no decree issued by a mosque, but a man named Anees verbally threatened the police because he was dissatisfied with their investigation into his son’s death. Sudarshan News’s reportage was grossly misleading and the truth was also pointed out by Baghpat police. However, Chavhanke defiantly stood by his outlet’s factually incorrect report.
2. Old video morphed with slogans calling to kill RSS workers
Sudarshan News played a video during a July 1, 2019 broadcast where sword-wielding people could be heard chanting slogans calling to kill RSS workers.
This video was morphed, found Alt News. Anti-RSS chants were added to the original video of a Muharram procession from Dehri, Bihar.
3. Differently-abled man portrayed as ‘Rohingya criminal’
In September 2017, Sudarshan News posted an image of a differently-abled man claiming that he was a ‘Rohingya criminal’ dragged by the police.
Suresh Chavhanke tweeted the article which is still available on his timeline.
SM Hoaxslayer had reported last year that the differently-abled man in the photo was actually an activist and a member of Bangladesh’s Gonojagoron Mancha. The photo is from the organisation’s protests which took place in 2014.
4. Reference to Bawana locals of Delhi as ‘Rohingyas’
The Delhi Minorities Commission (DMC) issued a notice to Sudarshan TV in May 2018 for airing a mischievous report that allegedly referred to some locals of north Delhi’s Bawana region as ‘Rohingyas’ and ‘Bangladeshis’.
The DMC also ordered the channel to broadcast an apology and submit an undertaking stating that no such reports will be telecast in future.
5. Linked Tablighi Ijtema with mob violence in Bulandshahr; police denied
On December 3, 2018, a cop was killed after a mob protesting alleged illegal cow slaughter clashed with the police in Siana tehsil of Bulandshahr district in Uttar Pradesh. “In the unrest following the Bulandshahr Ijtema, children are stuck in schools and crying, people are in the forest, they have shut the doors of their homes- residents in live conversation with Sudarshan News,” tweeted Chavhanke, suggesting that the Ijtema was somehow linked with the violence in which the cop was killed.
Bulandshahr police clarified via Twitter that the violence which shook the town was not related to the Ijtema gathering. Replying to Chavhanke’s tweet, the police made an appeal to not spread misinformation.
Alt News had debunked this claim in an earlier article.
6. Fake quote attributed to Shahruukh Khan
Sudarshan News in a May 18, 2014 broadcast, claimed that Bollywood actor Shahrukh Khan said that he will leave the country if PM Modi comes to power.
Khan never made the purported statement but a morphed tweet was attributed to him. Alt News had debunked this here.
7. Reported former PM Vajpayee’s death before the official announcement
On August 16, 2018, it was reported that former PM Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s health was in a critical condition. Many media outlets jumped the gun to publish ‘breaking news’ and broadcast Vajpayee’s death before an official announcement was made. AIIMS put out a press release stating that the former PM took his last breath at 5:05 PM. However, Sudarshan News had already declared him dead at 3 PM.
8. Claimed fake Ram Rahim in jail, real one abroad
In a comical Facebook Live last year, Suresh Chavhanke claimed that Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh was not lodged in jail after his rape conviction, but was living abroad since three months before the pronouncement of his sentence.
During the length of the 13-minute Live, he made absurd claims like the person who was arrested was not Ram Rahim but his duplicate. He added that a DNA test of the man imprisoned should be conducted to prove his identity.
This Facebook Live was aired from the official page of Sudarshan News on September 1, 2017, the same day a Hindustan Times article reported that an inmate lodged adjacent to Ram Rahim’s cell said that he heard the self-styled Godman scream at night and not consume any food out of fear.
SUDARSHAN NEWS’S STATEMENT
Alt News contacted Sudarshan News for comments on the frequent disinformation shared by the channel. Rana informed that the organisationcites ‘social media’ as a source whenever a piece of information is picked up from networking platforms. When asked if such content is verified before broadcast, the program head said that the channel informs viewers about viral content without claiming it’s true, or false.
The cases of misinformation listed earlier in this report contradict Rana’s statement as the channel has pushed unauthenticated social media posts as true. However, a major cause of concern is a news outlet’s acceptance of the fact that it publishes viral content without verification thus not only giving credence to false claims but also encouraging them.
Rana blamed ‘unsubstantiated’ social media posts and claimed that Sudarshan News has often provided clarification for misleading content. However, he was unable to recall specific cases.
Our request for a conversation with Suresh Chavhanke went unfulfilled.
Disinformation personally shared by Suresh Chavhanke
1. Claimed Nehru said he is ‘Hindu by accident’
On November 27, 2018, Chavhanke tweeted that India’s first prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru called himself a ‘Hindu by accident’. At the time of writing this article, Chavhanke’s tweet received over 2,300 likes and 900 retweets.
This identical claim has been debunked by Alt News multiple times in the past (1, 2). Nehru did not call himself a ‘Hindu by accident’ but he was described as ‘English by education, Muslim by culture and Hindu by an accident of birth’ by Hindu Mahasabha leader B R Nanda in his book ‘The Nehrus: Motilal and Jawaharlal‘.
2. Posted a video claiming Muslim boy tore the Indian flag
In a video viral on social media, a teenage boy was seen tearing the national flag while saying, “Main pakka Musalman hoon”. Alt News found that the boy actually belonged to the Hindu community and was posing as a Muslim to stir up a controversy. Among the ones who circulated the unauthenticated video was Suresh Chavhanke. He tweeted a longer version where the boy was abused, made to apologise and forced to say “Pakka Hindu hoon”. The tweet received nearly 2,000 retweets.
3. Images of Godhra riots used for hatemongering against Rohingyas
In September 2017, Chavhanke tweeted – “When Rohingya Muslims were being investigated in Jaipur, a crowd of 25,000 surrounded a police station…” His tweet ended with a #DeportRohingya appeal. Chavhanke later deleted the tweet after multiple users pointed out that the images were from Gujarat.
4. False claim of Naga Sadhu thrashed by ‘anti-Hindus’
Earlier in September 2018, Chavhanke appealed to prime minister Modi to take action against ‘anti-Hindus’ who thrashed a Naga Sadhu.
A similar claim was viral on social media and had been debunked by Alt News. The official twitter handle of Dehradun police had put out a statement clarifying – “The man is an imposter against whom a complaint has been filed for molesting a woman while being intoxicated.” The man wasn’t a Naga Sadhu but was begging for alms when he was beaten up by a Hindu family for allegedly molesting a woman of the house.
5. Claimed that Pakistani Islamic scholar Tariq Jamil was invited to Bulandshahr Ijtema
Tweeting a video of Jamil, where he can be heard terming Sikh Maharaja Ranjit Singh a “dacoit”, Chavhanke claimed that the Pakistani Islamic scholar was invited to the Ijtema held Bulandshahr, Uttar Pradesh.
Earlier in this article, Alt News had reported how Sudarshan News linked the Bulandsharhr violence to Tablighi Ijtema which took place in the city from December 1 to 3 last year. Tariq could not have been present in UP during this time because he was live-streaming a video from Pakistan on December 2.
Apart from circulating blatant disinformation, Sudarshan News’s content has also come in the crosshairs of the government and local police for allegedly igniting hate along communal/religious lines.
Booked by UP police for promoting enmity between religious groups
In April 2017, Sudarshan News and Suresh Chavhanke were booked by the Uttar Pradesh police on charges of allegedly hurting religious sentiments and promoting enmity between religious groups.
The police took action after citizens from different communities complained that the channel aired programs that promoted communal disharmony. After review, the police concluded that in several clips, Chavhanke allegedly made statements spreading “Hindu-Muslim hostility,” reported The Hindu.
According to a report by Hindustan Times, Chavhanke was arrested on April 14 and granted bail the next day. Earlier, the Centre had assured the Rajya Sabha of action against the media outlet.
Show-cause notice for allegedly instigating violence during Muzaffarnagar riots
In 2013, the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting sent a show-cause notice to Sudarshan News after complaints were filed that the channel was instigating violence during the Muzzafarnagar riots.
According to Business Standard, a senior official in the ministry said at the time, “We are monitoring the content aired by Sudarshan TV and we believe the channel is in violation of policies, as some of the content is believed to have instigated the violence. We have given them a show cause notice as we believe they should be given a chance to give their view. So far, we have only received complaints about Sudarshan TV and none of the other broadcasters.”
Chavhanke said in a response that they “have a clean history record and were only appealing to their viewers to remain calm.”
BJP Chattisgarh member files FIR against Sudarshan News for instigating hate
In a recent article, Newslaundry reported that Sudarshan News added communal colour to a land dispute matter in Chhattisgarh. “Dirty show of Jihadis in Chhattisgarh, threaten Hindu women with rape,” was the focus of the broadcast.
Following the channel’s report, Newslaundry reported that “on July 11, a resident named Sanjay Singh filed an FIR against Sudarshan’s bureau chief Yogesh Mishra, Vijaya Gupta, her daughter Karishma Gupta, and Omesh Visen, a Bajrang Dal leader and close friend of the Gupta family. Singh, a member of the BJP state executive committee, registered the FIR at Purani Basti Police Station under Section 153A of the Indian Penal Code.”
The channel’s editor-in-chief stood by the reportage.
Political patronage despite propagating misinformation
Suresh Chavhanke’s Twitter cover photo is with prime minister Narendra Modi, where both men are smiling at each other whilst greeting with namastes. Despite being a frequent purveyor of fake news, Chavhanke enjoys the company of influential personalities.
In August 2018, he tweeted images of a lunch gathering with vice president Venkaiah Naidu and compared him with former VP Hamid Ansari – “पिछले उपराष्ट्रपति
#HamidAnsariऔर वेंकैया जी में ज़मीन आसमान का अंतर दिखाई दिया ” Venkaiah ji is poles apart from former Vice President Hamid Ansari– translated).
Chavhanke seems to enjoy a cordial relationship with BJP MP Giriraj Singh who congratulated him on the 14th anniversary of Sudarshan News.
The Sudarshan News editor was also invited to prime minister Modi’s swearing-in ceremony.
Other prominent BJP leaders who share a friendly association with Chavhanke, often tweeting praises, are union ministers Ravi Shankar Prasad and Dharmendra Pradhan, MPs Vinay Sahasrabuddhe, Niranjan Jyoti, Hariom Pandey, Amar Singh and MLA T Raja Singh, among others,
Most articles published by Sudarshan News begin with an emotional pandering to its readers and most shows aired by the channelare replete with sensationalism. Despite being called out multiple times for pushing a sectarian narrative,the channel continues to polarise opinions, broadcast dangerous misinformation and enjoy political patronage. Any false report circulated by a media outlet with a substantial following might have serious consequences. Only on social media (Facebook and Twitter), Sudarshan News and Suresh Chavhanke have a combined following of over 13 lakh – their ability to shape public opinion is not one to be taken lightly.